Wednesday, January 16, 2013

Microteaching 2


Teacher: Miss May Nasr

Grade 8

Class period: 55 min

Date: January 7

Course Title: English for second language

Number of students: 30

Lesson Topic: Importance of Olive Trees



Lesson Objective:

Students should be able Speaking: to gather information (for discussion)

To formulate opinion (clustering)

to become more aware of the importance of preserving clean healthy environment.

Trees provide us with oxygen, food and beautify our environment, etc.

When you enter the UOB gate, what is the first thing that captured your eyes?

- Olive trees – benches where students sit. Why olive tree is so important and why it is distinguished from other trees? It is significant, noteworthy as its origin goes back to the history of mankind and the growth of civilization.

What do you know about this tree?

Draw a circle on board, clustering words



king: to gather information (for discussion)

To formulate opinion (clustering)

Listening: to gather and learn new information.

Reading: to analyze and interpret the reading and then write it in the writing task.

Subsidiary objective: students will be able to discuss the theme about importance of olive trees using the new vocabulary related to the topic.

Procedures:

Warm up activity. 3-4 mim

Students are asked certain question based on prior knowledge to start the lesson. Students are introduced to items related to olive trees to grab their attention.

Speaking: 10 min

Teacher engages students in a discussion about the topic through generating questions that will lead the discussion. Eliciting and clustering words.

When you enter the UOB gate, what is the first thing that captured your eyes?

Why olive tree is so important and why it is distinguished from other trees? What do you know about this tree?



Why olive oil is so important and why it is distinguished from other trees?

Reading: 8 min

Students skim and scan for specific and general details to enhance their knowledge about the importance of olive trees. Students will work in group to answer the comprehended questions.

Let student read the passage then teacher ask them to answer the comprehended questions.

Divide students into group of three to answer the questions. Then swap their papers to correct them.

Students will cut the correct answers and put them in a basket. These answers will be used listed and labeled on the poster.

Poster: 3 min

Creative and artistic: students will be motivated and involved in revising and labeling the important items those summaries the lesson.

Poster of Picasso’s picture dove of peace

Label



Listing board

Why olive trees are important to human beings?

What are the benefits of olive tree?

Writing: 25 min.

Persuasive writing and role play.

Write one paragraph. 10 min

Persuasive writing: Imagine you have a big piece of land planted olive and your parent wants to chop down the trees to build a factory. How do you convince them not to cut the trees to keep the land as it is and benefit from these olives trees?

Students individually do the writing task.

Role play. 15 min.

Group work: Then students are seated in pairs where they share each other’s ideas in order to write down a dialogue which will be acted in class.

Poster of Picasso’s picture dove

Label

Instructional Materials:

Olive branch, olive oil, olives, bar of soap, posters of olive trees and Picasso’s drawing “Dove of Peace, a booklet about olive “the olive tree in the Mediterranean”

Evaluation of the students:

Students are evaluated through their engagement in the activities and through labeling the poster which sum up the lesson. Feedback will be given later on, after implementing the whole lesson.

Assignment: internet research.

Search for similar trees that are well known in Lebanon and write about their benefits for human beings and environment.

For example, you could write about the benefits of fruitful trees like apples or forest trees like Cedars and Oak trees.

Comment on the lesson:

This lesson is implemented through a shy attempt to use art by presenting the poster activity. The use of authentic material and experiential learning is widely used. Also attention was paid to involve students with learning diversity through varying the activities.





Appendix A

Warm up

Why are trees important?

Students might answer: Trees provide us with oxygen, food and beautify our environment, etc. Identify the items related to olive tree.

Speaking:

When you enter the UOB gate, what is the first thing that captured your eyes?

- Olive trees – benches where students sit. Why olive tree is so important and why it is distinguished from other trees? It is significant, noteworthy as its origin goes back to the history of mankind and the growth of civilization.

What do you know about this tree?

Appendix B

Reading: to analyze and interpret the reading and then write it in the writing task.

Let student read the passage then teacher ask them to answer the comprehended questions.

Olive and Medicine

In earlier times olive oil was used therapeutically in many ways. Roman medicine favored the oil of the bitter wild olive.

Then and now, for instance, warm oil may be introduced to the ear as a remedy for inflammation or to loosen excess wax. Then and now, it is applied as a balm to burns and stings-as formerly to wounds.

Olive oil and other “good” or mono-unsaturated oils both lower “bad” LDL and simultaneously raise “good” HDL. Olive oil also has another advantage. It contains antioxidants, which offset “bad” free radicals. While it is at it, olive oil contains phytoestrogens, which counteract bone loss.

1- When was olive oil used to treat people?

2- For what purposes was warm olive oil used?

3- Is olive oil good for bad LDL?

4- What are the other advantages of olive oil?

5- In your opinion, do you think that olive oil is so important and why?

Poster: 3 min

Creative and artistic: students will be motivated and involved in revising and labeling the important items those summaries the lesson.

Poster of Picasso’s picture dove of peace

Label



Why olive trees are important to human beings?

What are the benefits of olive tree?

Appendix c

Writing: 25 min.

Persuasive writing and role play.

Lebanon is well known by its olive trees.

Olive trees are grown in almost every region of Lebanon and Koura is well known by its olive trees that grow on its plains and hills since ancient times. The golden olive oil and tasty olives have contributed in enriching our society and in building prosperous future for our sons since hundreds of years. Our ancestors plowed and cared for their land to educate their children.

Write one paragraph. 10 min

Persuasive writing: Imagine you have a big piece of land planted olive and your parent wants to chop down the trees to build a factory. How do you convince them not to cut the trees to keep the land as it is and benefit from these olives trees?

Students individually do the writing task.

Role play. 15 min.

Group work: Then students are seated in pairs where they share each other’s ideas in order to write down a dialogue which will be acted in class.

Olive tree let’s encourage the plantation of more olive trees Long lasting trees

Olive tree is an evergreen tree.

What does the olive tree symbolizes?

Peace and Tranquility, Evergreen, History and Civilization,

Provides us with Delicious and healthy olive oil, Tasty black and green olive,

Wood Source of Heat, Furniture.

Used in Medicine

Medical usage. Warm oil as a remedy for the ear. Applied as a balm Lower “bad” LDL

Provides us with Oxygen Good for Environment







Microteaching 2

Teacher: Miss May Nasr

Grade 8

Class period: 55 min

Date: January 7

Course Title: English for second language

Number of students: 30

Lesson Objectives:

Students should be able to:

1. To identify vocabulary words relevant to the importance of olive trees.

2. To elicit new vocabulary words related to the importance of olive trees.

3. To use fourteen new vocabulary words related to the olive in medicine and write them in meaningful sentences.

Procedures:

Warm up Activity. 3-4 mim. Use of relia

students are asked certain questions based on their prior knowledge of trees. To grab their attention, students are introduced to items related to olive trees by the use of realia

Speaking Activity: 10 min

Teacher engages students in a discussion about the topic by generating questions that will lead the discussion. Appendix A

Reading Activity: 8 min

Students will learn new vocabulary words. They skim and scan to enhance their knowledge about the importance of olive trees. Students work in groups to answer the comprehension questions. Appendix B

• Let students read the passage then the teacher asks them to answer the comprehension questions.

• Divide students into groups of three to answer the questions. Then the groups swap their papers and correct them.

• Students cut the correct answers and place them in a basket. These answers will be used to list and label the poster in the next activity.

Poster Activity: 10 min

Appendix C

Poster of Picasso’s picture “Dove of Peace” is used to reinforce and check the reading and speaking comprehension.

Creative and artistic: students are motivated and involved in revising and labeling the important items those related to the importance of olive tree, thus summarizing the lesson.

Writing: 25 min.

Role-play. Appendix D

Role-play will be acted to enhance the practice of the new vocabulary and use them in writing. The characters are parents and two sons.

Group work: Then students are seated in pairs to discuss their ideas. Then they write down a dialogue which will be acted in class.

Instructional Materials:

Olive branch, olive oil, olives, bar of soap, posters of olive trees and Picasso’s drawing “Dove of Peace, a booklet about olive “the olive tree in the Mediterranean”

Evaluation of the students:

Students are evaluated according to their engagement in the activities, ability to use these new vocabularies in correct sentences and ability to label the poster which sum up the lesson. Feedback will be given later, after the implementation of the whole lesson.

Assignment: Internet research.

Search for similar trees that are well-known in Lebanon and write about their benefits for human beings and the environment.

For example, you could write about the benefits of fruit trees such as apples trees, or forest trees such as Cedars or Oak trees.

Comment on the lesson:

This lesson is implemented through a shy attempt to use art by presenting the poster activity. The use of authentic material and experiential learning is widely used. Also, attention was paid to involve students with learning diversity by varying the activities.

Exploitability of the lesson.

This lesson could be done by presenting a video about the extracting of olive oil or by taking students on a trip to see the collection of olive during the season.







Appendix A

Why are trees important?

Students might answer: Trees provide us with oxygen, food and beautify our environment, etc. Identify the items related to olive tree.

Speaking:

When you enter the UOB, what is the first thing that captures your eye?

Why is the olive tree so important and why it is distinguished from other trees?

It is significant and noteworthy as its origin goes back to the history of mankind and the growth of civilization.

What do you know about this tree?

Appendix B

Vocabulary words: therapeutically, wild olive, remedy, inflammation, wax, balm, stings, wounds, mono-unsaturated oils, LDL and HDL, antioxidants, offset, bad free radicals, hytoestrogen.



Reading: to analyze and interpret the reading and then write it in the writing task.

Let student read the passage then teacher ask them to answer the comprehension questions.

Olive and Medicine

In earlier times olive oil was used therapeutically in many ways. Roman medicine favored the oil of the bitter wild olive.

Then and now, for instance, warm oil may be introduced to the ear as a remedy for inflammation or to loosen excess wax. Then and now, it is applied as a balm to burns and stings-as formerly to wounds.

Olive oil and other “good” or mono-unsaturated oils both lower “bad” LDL and simultaneously raise “good” HDL. Olive oil also has another advantage. It contains antioxidants, which offset “bad” free radicals. While it is at it, olive oil contains phytoestrogen, which counteract bone loss.

6- When was olive oil used to treat people?

7- For what purposes was warm olive oil used?

8- Is olive oil good for bad LDL?

9- What are the other advantages of olive oil?

10- In your opinion, do you think that olive oil is important and why?



Appendix C

Poster: 3 min

Poster of Picasso’s picture dove of peace

Why olive trees are important to human beings?

What are the benefits of olive tree?

Label: Olive tree

Let’s encourage the plantation of more olive trees Provides us with Oxygen Good for Environment

Long lasting trees

Evergreen

Olive tree is an evergreen tree.

What does the olive tree symbolizes?

Peace and Tranquility, Evergreen, History and Civilization,

Provides us with Food

Delicious and healthy olive oil, Tasty black and green olive,

Provides us with Wood

Source of Heat, Furniture.

Used in Medicine

Medical usage. Warm oil as a remedy for the ear. Applied as a balm Lower “bad” LDL

Appendix D

Writing: 25 min.

Role-play.

Based on the vocabulary that student learned about the importance of olive trees, students have to demonstrate a role play to practice the usage of these vocabularies.

Lebanon is well known by its olive trees.

Olive trees are grown in almost every region of Lebanon. Since ancient times, Koura is well known by its olive trees that grow on its plains and hills. The golden olive oil and tasty olives have contributed in enriching our society and in building prosperous future for our sons since hundreds of years. Our ancestors plowed and cared for their land to educate their children.

Now the prices of land will make a fortune.

The family consists of parents and two sons.

• Parents want to sell the land to become rich.

• Sons want to keep the land and benefit from its wonderful olive trees.

Each character will have a colored card that disguises him from the others. The four characters have to list the vocabulary words on these which they will use when acting.

Group work: Then students are seated in pairs to discuss their ideas. Then they write down a dialogue which will be acted in class

Next hour

We are going to write a persuasive essay.

Imagine you have a big piece of land planted olive and your parents want to chop down the trees to build a factory. How do you convince them not to cut the trees and benefit from these olive trees? In other words, what would you do cut the trees or build a factory?

Students individually do the writing task.









Reflection on my microteaching

In writing my second microteaching, my main concern was to execute a well organized lesson where the objectives are clearly stated, the text is coherent, well contextualized and the activities are written with clear instructions. I wanted each part of the lesson to be linked with each other, so that when implementing the lesson the shift from the introductory activity to the developmental activity and the to the closing activity will be smooth and clear. I tried my best to search for materials that will raise the students’ interest, make use of new vocabulary by generating question and eliciting words, by learning the meaning of new vocabulary and using them in correct sentence, by discussing and answering the comprehension questions and writing the essay later on. I was occupied with my lesson, generating question and trying to anticipate what the students might answer, clustering the vocabulary and searching for a reading activity that is up to the level of the students till the extent that I thought everything is just right.

I was obsessed by writing clear instructions especially that in my previous microteaching, my writing instructions were not clear and as a result I could not demonstrate my lesson of subject verb agreement as I had planned. I anticipated that everyone knows the pronouns in the “third person singular” and the pronouns in the “plural form”, for this I wrote my instructions as I did in activity 2. It might have been clearer If I had written them, as I do in my class at school, such as “rewrite the activity using pronouns: he, she, it instead of the pronoun I and “rewrite the activity using the pronouns: you, we, they instead of the pronoun I”. Having this in mind, I wanted my second micro teaching lesson to be well organized with clear objectives that meets the instructions. The objective may not have been clear and as a result, they were revisited. An error with respect to typing the document was done. It may have been confusing for students. This produced a chaotic reaction and made me search for a particular content. Therefore, this has been corrected and the improved lesson plan reflects a coherent listing.

Critical incidents happen and the teacher has to be well prepared to handle the situations. Dr Annous has always warned that these incidents might happen and as I mentioned above it really affected my presentation. I was late and interrupted Lina’s lesson but she handled the problem in a very professional way. I tried to be calm but I was worried and afraid that students might not respond as I wanted which will affect my time line for the activities. I was presenting my lesson but my mind was thinking of what might happen next. For this incomplete sentences occur such as “this is for to eat” instead “this is to eat” and saying AUB instead of UOB that made the branch of olive is its logo and we forgot to mention it. Asking students “who will start instead of please, answer” and saying “for example’, a lot where there is no need to say it. Mixing Arabic with English at times such as “Nouh” instead of Noah; and “yeani” instead of “this means”, etc. The clustering of words can benefit from being more organized so that categories are made clearer. The explanation of the new vocabulary in the reading part should be more emphasized and explained even if the students have said that they understood the lesson and everything is clear. Asking the students to cut the papers themselves and stick them on the poster to make them sum up the lesson and check what they understood from the lesson. The time line was extended to 10 minutes in the revisited lesson plan.

Clear visual aids and the use of realia encourage students to elicit and use their imagination to formulate sentences as possible and reinforces the use of spoken or written words. Strong interaction and engagement with students as the students were involved in the activities. Positive class dynamics as I tried my best to integrate the activities that motivates student and engage them paying attention to students with diverse learning styles. Also, students were cooperative and responding properly to my instructions as they were working together and in groups. Time table of activities was respected.

Thank you my dear friends

Thank you Dr. Annous



Sunday, December 9, 2012

Reflection on Mrs.Joanna's lesson


            Mrs. Joanna is a unique lady who possesses a charming energetic personality. She is creative, imaginative and artistic by nature in class and anywhere. She entered our classroom carrying stuff that usually goes to the waste basket or for recycling. There were bags filled with cardboard, stationary, and boxes of various colors, shapes and sizes. Her touch of art was clearly visible by using personification, as she placed the scarf over her posters an image of human being attending her poetry exhibition could be interpreted in our mind. The table was full and I found myself engaged in finding room for her to display her posters. I was searching for things that I might find in my classroom to make her posters steady; wondering about what her next step might be. Mrs. Joanna started by advising us that we should always be prepared and ready, to be well equipped showing us her pencil case, stapler, scotch tape, scissors, crayons, A4 papers and also nylon bags. She was pointing at the frames and edges of her posters coaching us to make ours clear, neat and to leave a little white border to make it look better. She was aware of every single incident related to her lesson. Then she started generating her questions, what can we do with a big “fridge box” and she continued like that until she heard the magic word “puppet” her lessons’ objective. She cut a medium size box and created a “puppet theater” with a white curtain made out of the nylon bag. While cutting the cardboard, she was very professional and she did not forget to create a painting background to make her theater appealing to the audiences. She was directing us to let our students do things themselves, to paint, glue and cut their drawings. She was the master and we were her puppet toys as she asked us to write within 10 minutes a story and perform it in the puppet theater. We found ourselves involved in writing a dialogue, creating characters, drawing and coloring them, cutting their shapes and gluing them on A4 paper stick, then playing our roles and acting.
  Mrs. Joanna manipulated art to facilitate learning. She demonstrated a lesson in a smooth way moving for one activity to another linking them together without the students’ recognition of the transaction. She used story telling from beginning to the end of her lesson as she was narrating to us about her life and experiences, about the kid wearing the hat on Independence Day, and about the edges of the frames, drawing. Her intention was to guide, prompt, and encourage us to be creative and to involve our students in doing their part of work. She used critical thinking by making us deduce her “rules” which she did not state, but lead us to conclude them. Everything she said or did was implemented in her lesson. She used inductive method, inquiry for experiential learning in a communicative way and she made the students collaborate to produce their puppet show. We were engaged in writing the activity in pairs. By doing this the students used brainstorming and the four skills, as we were speaking when discussing our script, writing it then reading it and later on, when acting we were the real audiences listening and watching each other puppet show. The learning was teacher centered and student centered in the same session. All This proves how professional Mrs. Joanna is.

Thursday, November 29, 2012


Indirect Instructional Strategies using the inductive method

Teacher: Miss May                                                          Grade Level: Grade seven- beginners_____
Room Number: 6                                                             Course Title: English for second language_
Class Period:  50min.                                                       Lesson Topic: Subject Verb agreement____
Date: Nov.26                      ______                 
No of Sts: __30_                                     

1-      Lesson Objectives:
A)     Students should be able to identify, practice and use subject verb agreement accurately.
B)      Student should be able to differentiate how subject verb agreement is used in different grammatical structures in the present simple.
2-      Procedures (and number of minutes is 20 minutes)
·         Introductory activities (2-3 min)
a)      Teacher introduces the students to the various flowers pictures, Virtuous Woman magazine, real flowers, and tools and materials which will be used to plant.
b)      Teacher asks students to label the yellow card paper to its object. (1 min)
·         Developmental activities (4-14 min)
Activity 1.
a)      Teacher asks students to read the paragraph. (2 min)
b)      Teacher asks students to work in pair to answer the comprehension questions. (3 min).
Activity 2.
a)      Teacher plants the bulb with the help of the students. (2-3 min)
b)      Teacher divides students into group of three to do activity 2. (3-4 min)
c)       Students swap their writings and provide peer editing. (2 min)                
                In groups of three, students have to rewrite the activity. Group A: write the activity using nouns or pronouns in the third person singular while Group B: write the activity using pronouns or nouns in the plural form.
·         Closing activities. (2-3 min)
Teacher asks students about the rule without stating it. Students can predict and deduce the rule of subject verb agreement.
a)       Jigsaw activity
Students have to put the sentences in the correct form.

3-      Instructional Materials
Various flowers pictures, Virtuous Woman magazine, real flowers, tools and materials for planting like soil, water, a pot and planting tools. Cardboard to label names of the objects, and cardboard envelopes to put in the unjumble words in to make sentences in for the jigsaw, work sheet and board. 

4-      Evaluation of students
Students’ achievements could be evaluated through their engagement in the activities.
During pair work and group work activities, the teacher could interfere and provide feedback if needed.

5-       Assignment
Write a paragraph about your favorite hobby.
6-      Comments on the Lessons and Ideas for Revision
·         This lesson plan was written on the assumption that teacher has explained the pronouns, nouns and verbs in the present form and the students have practiced and understood the material.
·         Teacher will not state the rule unless the students are unable to proceed. Then deductive method is used.
·         This lesson is implemented through the use of authentic and genuine material that is suitable for the level of the students. Every student is involved in these amusing and communicative activities. Students will learn through experiential method.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appendix. A
In my free time I like to plant flowers. Flowers are of various types and colors. Some have roots, like roses and some have bulbs like narcissi and tulips. Roses differ in size and shape. They can grow into trees, bushes or baby roses. Narcissi are always white but tulips vary in colors and sizes.  For example, there are red, yellow and even black Tulips. A garden full of flowers is a source of happiness, peace and relaxation.
Answer these questions:
1-      What do you do in your free time?
2-      Do you like gardening?
3-      How do flowers differ?
4-      Does any of you like to plant flowers?
5-      Which is your favorite type of flowers?
6-      Are flowers a source of happiness to you and why?
Appendix. B
I fill three quarter of the pot with good fertile soil. Then I plant the bulb and cover it with a mixed of top and fertile soil. I cover the bulb with about 2 inches of soil. Then I water the bulb. Every two three days, I water a little bit depending on the humidity of the soil. Finally I keep the pot in a sunny place.
Students deduce the rule.
       -    In groups of three, students have to rewrite the activity.
-          Group A: write the activity using nouns or pronouns in the third person singular while Group B: write the activity using pronouns or nouns in the plural form.
-          Students swap their papers and peer feedback is provided.

-          Appendix. C
Students are dived in two groups A and B. sentences are distributed among the two yellow envelop.

-          Jigsaw
1-      Eric and Jimmy like to plant roses.
2-      My uncle spends his free time gardening.
3-      Peter and Jack read classic stories.
4-      There is one sentence left.
5-      There are many colors in the rainbow.
6-      Plants need sun, water, and soil to grow.


        -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Microteaching Reflection
This microteaching lesson plan was designed to be presented in an authentic, communicative way that enables students to identify, practice and differentiate the subject verb agreement in a real genuine setting using the inductive method. I wanted to be creative and I wanted the students to learn the subject verb agreement through experimenting a real planting session. I thought that I will experiment a new teaching method by generating questions and demanding answers to implement my lesson plan. In order to do this, I introduced the students to the various types of flowers thinking that these activities might help them to formulate and write sentences using the subject verb agreement as I proceed through the lesson. When students produce their writing sentences and paragraphs I can correct their errors and provide feedback. In order to meet my objective, I wanted students to write complete simple sentences where the subject and verb agree. My intention was to make students realize the differences between the first personal pronouns, second personal and third personal pronoun. As some grade seventh ESL students' are unaware of these differences.
 I might have some gaps in implementing my lesson plan but this doesn’t mean that my instructions to rewrite the paragraph in groups were unclear (activity 2, appendix B). If the instructions were not clear then how could Lina and Rula proceed in their writing paragraph?
 I was nervous and disappointed because the alleged time for this activity was passing and as a result the peer editing activity which is based on this writing activity could not be implemented. On the other hand, time management and class management was not executed as it should be. If things were done as I planned for these writing activities, maybe I could have done the jigsaw activity and finished within the time limit. May be I could have presented a lesson where students could deduce the rule and I could assess the students and provide feedback of subject verb agreement. I should have been firm and precise in performing my role as a teacher.  

Sunday, November 18, 2012

The Indirect Method Model:  Sue’s classroom  incorporate one of the central principles of the indirect Method Model the use of questions to guide the search and discovery process using Jellybeans to creat an authentic problem requiring her learners to count and organize data doing math and graphing with a real world problem.
This video presents Sue as a well organized professional teacher who is knowledgeable of every single incident related to her classroom. Equipments and materials used in her classroom are necessary for math class and are suitable for her students’ needs’ as they are second-grader learners. Sue used real Jellybeans that children adore their taste. Jellybeans are countable and colored and therefore, a perfect choice for solving math problems and representing graph. Her class is student centered as students sit in small groups around tables and she moves among them to assess and guide them when needed. She has good classroom management and she is aware of her students’ diversity and cultural background. Her timeline is good, not more than fifteen minutes which is good for her students’ age to keep them motivated and involved in learning. Content organization was about 2-3 minutes where the teacher introduced Jelly beans and let student taste them thus using the five senses, touch, sight and taste which will promote the students to think and later on raise questions. Question time line was about 3 minutes and then deeper questions while presenting the graph was about 5mimutes and the later phase for students’ self evaluation and providing feedback was also about 5 minutes.
Sue used the inductive and deductive methods which are perfect for inquiry and problem solving. Inductive was used to promote questions sue lets student discover knowledge and understanding through their mistakes not just by telling them what she wants them to learn. Towards the end Sue used the deductive method when she reviewed the addition and subtraction: how many more people liked the red Jellybeans? / How many people are different / how do you solve the problem? There was the voice of a narrator giving instructions to what the teacher was doing while conducting her lesson and informing us that the curriculum was planed from explicit to implicit which enlighten justify for us the usage of the indirect method . Sue’s questions aided her learners search for discovery of meaning by resolving problems and contradictions when she let them discover and figure out what Jellybeans are. She did not give them answers she let the student taste and she provided jellybeans sheets to raise questions to figure out what they are. Then she identified the graph concept thus probing deeper for more information through students’ responses. Students analyzed the graph by answering the teachers’ questions. How many people like green?/ student answers 9. 3 people like black. Teacher extended discussion to newer area when one student answer was wrong so she directed the student saying “we wanted to know the difference” Students stands near the picture of the graph and gave the right answer. Students could interpret the graph and by this the teacher passes responsibility back to the learner